Data and provenance
What the Atlas, Evidence and tools are built from.
Every record on this site comes from one set of research data. This page lists what is in it, where each part came from, how the relationships are evidenced and what still needs review.
Dataset inventory
| Dataset | Records | Origin | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Atlas domains | 18 | Supplied and drafted | Domain names, stages, one-line summaries and search synonyms were written during the build. They were not re-compared with the supplied taxonomy because the supplied files are no longer in the workspace. |
| Atlas subtopics | 54 | Supplied research file | Names and summaries from the supplied package v1-0-2 taxonomy file. |
| Atlas relationships | 36 | Supplied research file | Endpoints, relation types and rationales from the supplied relationships file. The R01-R36 identifiers are assigned here by file order. |
| Relationship evidence classification | 36 | Drafted for review | Which of the six evidence categories applies to each relationship was drafted during the build and needs owner review. The uncertainty statements are general text by relation type. |
| Evidence sources | 12 | Supplied research file | From the supplied seed file. Changes made are listed under Identified changes. Every record is unreviewed. |
| Relationship draft analyses | 36 | Drafted for review | Seven-part drafts (relationship, mechanism, importance, what it could change, source support, limits, what would settle it). Marked DRAFT_NEEDS_EXPERT_REVIEW. No source support is registered for any of them. |
| Staged candidate sources | 80 | Supplied research file | Held for checking only. Not part of the register, not exported, not shown by title. 7 match existing register records by link and 73 are new. None is verified. |
| Materials | 8 | Drafted for review | Definitions and 'not the same as' notes were written from the brief. |
| Objectives | 7 | Drafted for review | Written from the brief. |
| Pathway options | 8 | Drafted for review | Inputs, outputs, residuals, unknowns and gates are drafted general statements, not sourced findings. |
| Pathway gates | 5 | Drafted for review | Five staged gates, all shown as not evidenced. |
Identified changes to supplied content
- SRC-004: removed a stray '(Date)' from the date field. It now reads 'Date to be rechecked'.
- SRC-012: the 'what it establishes' text was rewritten to 'Only that the separate Awonow identity has a public site. A related party, not an independent source.' The supplied text was 'Public site for Rohan Michael Brown/Awonow.'
- All sources: the 'establishes' field carries the same supplied text as the summary where the supplied file gave one description.
- Relationship identifiers R01-R36 and their evidence classification were added; the supplied relationship text is unchanged.
Disclosure status
What this site publishes, and what it deliberately does not.
- Atlas domains, subtopics and relationships
- Public explanatory contentGeneral scientific and operational relationships. No formulations, specifications or site records.
- Staged candidate sources (80)
- Held backRecorded for checking only. Their titles and links are not exported or shown until each has been checked and approved for publication.
- Evidence sources
- Public referencesPublicly available documents only, with links to the publisher.
- Pathways and calculators
- Public, illustrativeGeneric statements and worked examples with stated assumptions. No proprietary process parameters.
- Enquiries sent through the site
- PrivateNever part of any export or public page.
- Formulations, manufacturing specifications, restricted engineering documents, financial models, private Awonow development material
- Not publishedNone of these is held in the site's code or data. Any future addition needs a disclosure decision first.
Reconciliation checks
Computed from the running data each time this page loads. They test structure and counts. They cannot confirm that the text matches the supplied files word for word.
- Pass18 domains18 found
- PassEvery domain has exactly 3 subtopics3,3,3,3,3,3,3,3,3,3,3,3,3,3,3,3,3,3
- Pass54 subtopics54 found
- PassSubtopic names unique54 unique
- PassNo empty subtopic summariesall populated
- Pass36 relationships36 found
- PassRelationship endpoints are valid domainsall endpoints exist
- PassNo duplicate relationships36 unique
- PassEvery relationship has a rationaleall populated
- PassRelationship records match edges one to one36 records
- Pass12 evidence sources12 found
- PassSource ids unique12 unique
- PassSource links unique and httpsall https
- PassSource domains refer to real Atlas domainsall valid
- Pass36 relationship draft records, one per relationship36 drafts
- Pass80 candidate sources staged, none verified80 staged
- PassNo source marked reviewed0 reviewed
- PassNo relationship claims direct supportdirect and qualifying lists empty
How relationships are evidenced
- Direct supporting evidence 0 of 36
- A reviewed scientific or technical source that itself establishes this relationship.
- Qualifying or contradictory evidence 0 of 36
- A reviewed source that limits, conditions or contradicts the relationship.
- Established engineering or mathematical dependency 6 of 36
- Follows from a definition, mass or energy balance or a documented equation. No citation is registered yet.
- Editorial systems synthesis 27 of 36
- VRCRI's reasoned connection between topics. Not itself evidence.
- Research hypothesis requiring investigation 3 of 36
- A plausible connection that has to be tested before it can be relied on.
- Contextual references 36 of 36
- Sources about the same area that do not establish this particular relationship.
No relationship has direct supporting or qualifying evidence registered, because none of the 12 sources has been reviewed. Contextual references are same-domain sources that do not establish the particular relationship.
Review queue
Relationships ranked by how much they need direct supporting evidence. The score adds points for: no direct evidence, hypothesis or editorial basis, few or no contextual sources, and relevance to regulatory, verification or outcome claims.
| Rank | Relationship | Basis | Score | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | R24 K to Moutcome | Research hypothesis requiring investigation | 8 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Stated as a hypothesis; Few contextual sources; Bears on a regulatory, verification or outcome claim |
| 2 | R04 B to Cconstraint | Editorial systems synthesis | 7 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources; Bears on a regulatory, verification or outcome claim |
| 3 | R08 D to Kconstraint | Editorial systems synthesis | 7 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources; Bears on a regulatory, verification or outcome claim |
| 4 | R18 H to Revidence required | Editorial systems synthesis | 7 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources; Bears on a regulatory, verification or outcome claim |
| 5 | R20 I to Kevidence required | Editorial systems synthesis | 7 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources; Bears on a regulatory, verification or outcome claim |
| 6 | R22 J to Pconstraint | Editorial systems synthesis | 7 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources; Bears on a regulatory, verification or outcome claim |
| 7 | R23 J to Kconstraint | Editorial systems synthesis | 7 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources; Bears on a regulatory, verification or outcome claim |
| 8 | R26 L to Hevidence required | Editorial systems synthesis | 7 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources; Bears on a regulatory, verification or outcome claim |
| 9 | R31 O to Revidence required | Editorial systems synthesis | 7 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources; Bears on a regulatory, verification or outcome claim |
| 10 | R33 P to Qconstraint | Editorial systems synthesis | 7 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources; Bears on a regulatory, verification or outcome claim |
| 11 | R13 F to Jconstraint | Editorial systems synthesis | 6 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Bears on a regulatory, verification or outcome claim |
| 12 | R16 G to Hevidence required | Editorial systems synthesis | 6 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Bears on a regulatory, verification or outcome claim |
| 13 | R17 H to Jconstraint | Editorial systems synthesis | 6 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Bears on a regulatory, verification or outcome claim |
| 14 | R19 I to Jmaterial flow | Research hypothesis requiring investigation | 6 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Stated as a hypothesis; Few contextual sources |
| 15 | R25 K to Mfeedback | Research hypothesis requiring investigation | 6 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Stated as a hypothesis; Few contextual sources |
| 16 | R35 R to Pconstraint | Editorial systems synthesis | 6 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Bears on a regulatory, verification or outcome claim |
| 17 | R01 A to Hdependency | Editorial systems synthesis | 5 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources |
| 18 | R02 A to Cmaterial flow | Editorial systems synthesis | 5 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources |
| 19 | R06 C to Idependency | Editorial systems synthesis | 5 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources |
| 20 | R07 C to Ddependency | Editorial systems synthesis | 5 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources |
| 21 | R10 E to Qtradeoff | Editorial systems synthesis | 5 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources |
| 22 | R14 G to Gconstraint | Established engineering or mathematical dependency | 5 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Few contextual sources; Bears on a regulatory, verification or outcome claim |
| 23 | R21 J to Jdependency | Editorial systems synthesis | 5 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources |
| 24 | R28 M to Nfeedback | Editorial systems synthesis | 5 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources |
| 25 | R29 N to Qdependency | Editorial systems synthesis | 5 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources |
| 26 | R32 P to Qdependency | Editorial systems synthesis | 5 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources |
| 27 | R34 Q to Nfeedback | Editorial systems synthesis | 5 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only; Few contextual sources |
| 28 | R05 C to Ematerial flow | Editorial systems synthesis | 4 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only |
| 29 | R27 M to Rfeedback | Editorial systems synthesis | 4 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only |
| 30 | R30 O to Qdependency | Editorial systems synthesis | 4 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only |
| 31 | R36 R to Mfeedback | Editorial systems synthesis | 4 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Editorial synthesis only |
| 32 | R03 B to Cmaterial flow | Established engineering or mathematical dependency | 3 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Few contextual sources |
| 33 | R11 F to Fmaterial flow | Established engineering or mathematical dependency | 3 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Few contextual sources |
| 34 | R12 F to Ndependency | Established engineering or mathematical dependency | 3 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Few contextual sources |
| 35 | R15 G to Gmaterial flow | Established engineering or mathematical dependency | 3 | No direct supporting evidence registered; Few contextual sources |
| 36 | R09 E to Ndependency | Established engineering or mathematical dependency | 2 | No direct supporting evidence registered |